Gaming on a Budget: Quality Experiences Without Overspending

---

When I started gaming, I bought everything that looked interesting. Three years later, I owned 140 games—80 of them unplayed, £2,000 spent unwisely.

Now I own 45 games, all regularly played, and my annual game budget stays under £150. The gaming is better. The guilt is gone.

The True Cost of Board Gaming

Purchase Price Is Misleading

A £60 game played 60 times costs £1 per play. A £15 game played once costs £15 per play.

Cost-per-play formula: Purchase price ÷ Number of plays = Real value

The Real Budget Drains

Impulse buying: FOMO purchases rarely see play Kickstarter pledges: Often overpriced, often disappointing Complete-set collecting: Buying every expansion regardless of need New hotness chasing: Games become old hotness quickly

The Budget Gamer's Hierarchy

From cheapest to most expensive:

1. Play Games You Already Own (£0)

The cheapest game is the one already on your shelf. Many collections contain unplayed treasures.

Action: Before buying anything new, play every unplayed game once. Cull what you dislike; keep what you love.

2. Borrow From Friends (£0)

Social gamers share. Ask to borrow before buying.

Action: Propose a borrowing network with your gaming group. Everyone benefits.

3. Board Game Cafés (£5-10/visit)

Access hundreds of games for a small entry fee. Perfect for testing before purchasing.

Action: Visit monthly. Try games you're considering. Only buy confirmed favourites.

4. Library Games (£0)

Many public libraries now stock board games for borrowing. Check your local branch.

5. Secondhand Purchase (40-70% of retail)

Games in "Like New" condition play identically to retail purchases.

Where to buy:

• BoardGameGeek Marketplace
• Facebook Marketplace
• eBay (check condition carefully)
• Charity shops
• Local game shop used sections

6. Sales and Deals (20-50% off)

Patience saves significantly:

• Black Friday/Cyber Monday
• Boxing Day/January sales
• Amazon Lightning Deals
• Publisher clearances
• Store closing sales

7. Retail Purchase (Full price)

Sometimes necessary for new releases or local shop support. But should be minority of purchases.

Building a Budget Collection

The £100 Starter Collection

Five games that cover major categories:

Price: ~£30 (or £15-20 secondhand)

Price: ~£15 new

Price: ~£10 new

Price: ~£8 new

Fifth game of your choice: £20-25 for something matching your interests (co-op, strategy, etc.)

Total: Under £100, covers most gaming needs.

Budget Expansion Path

Once you have essentials, add based on gaps:

Need cooperative: Pandemic (£30) or The Crew (£12) Need strategy: Azul (£25) or Splendor (£25) Need two-player: Jaipur (£15) or 7 Wonders Duel (£20) Need party: Wavelength (£30) or Just One (£20)

Secondhand Buying Strategies

Condition Grading

Mint/Sealed: Never opened. Unnecessary for playing. Like New: Opened, unpunched or played once. Ideal purchase. Very Good: Light wear, complete. Usually fine. Good: Noticeable wear, possibly missing pieces. Verify contents. Acceptable: Heavy wear. Usually avoid.

Where to Look

BoardGameGeek Marketplace:

• Largest selection
• Seller ratings provide security
• International shipping available

Facebook Marketplace:

• Local pickup saves shipping
• Variable pricing (often good deals)
• Less protection than BGG

eBay:

• Buyer protection strong
• Prices sometimes inflated
• Watch for missing components

Charity Shops:

• Unpredictable but cheap
• Check completeness in-store
• Best finds require regular visiting

Price Benchmarking

Before buying secondhand, check:

• Current retail price
• BGG Marketplace recent sales
• eBay completed listings

Pay no more than 60-70% of retail for "Very Good" condition.

Smart New Purchasing

When buying new, minimise cost:

Price Tracking

CamelCamelCamel: Track Amazon price history. Buy at lows.

BoardGamePrices.co.uk: Compare across UK retailers.

Newsletter subscriptions: Retailers announce sales to subscribers first.

Bulk Buying

Combine orders to hit free shipping thresholds. Coordinate with friends.

Local Shop Value

Local game shops often cost 10-20% more than online. But they provide:

• Immediate availability
• Expert recommendations
• Community space
• Try-before-you-buy
• Local economy support

Worth premium for important games or when browsing.

The Anti-Budget Traps

Kickstarter FOMO

"Exclusive" content creates urgency. But:

• Most Kickstarter games reach retail
• Retail versions often improved
• Exclusives rarely enhance gameplay significantly
• Shipping costs add substantially

Expansion Addiction

Base games provide 90% of the experience. Expansions add variety but rarely necessity. Buy expansions only after exhausting base game replay value.

Collection Pride

Instagram game shelves create false aspirations. A small, played collection beats a large, neglected one.

New Release Chasing

Games don't expire. Year-old games play identically to launch-day copies—at half the price. Let others beta-test; buy proven favourites.

Budget Gaming Lifestyle

The Library Mindset

Treat your collection like a library: games come and go. Sell what you've finished to fund what you want.

Cycle: Buy secondhand → Play thoroughly → Sell for similar price → Repeat

Some games cost effectively £0-5 net after resale.

Shared Collections

Gaming groups can pool resources:

• Each person specialises (one buys co-ops, one buys party games)
• Access expands without individual cost
• Reduces duplication

Print-and-Play

Many excellent games have free print-and-play versions:

• Designers release for testing
• Older games in public domain
• Official P&P editions (Secret Hitler, others)

Effort required, but cost effectively zero.

Value Gaming Recommendations

Games delivering exceptional cost-per-play:

Under £10

• Love Letter — 16 cards, infinite plays
• Skull — Coasters and bluffing
• The Mind — Cards 1-100, shared experience
• Hanabi — Cooperative card puzzling

Under £20

• The Crew — Campaign trick-taking
• Codenames — Party essential
• Sushi Go! — Drafting in a tin
• Coup — Bluffing micro-game
• 6 Nimmt! — Up to 10 players

Under £30

• Ticket to Ride — Gateway classic
• Azul — Abstract beauty
• Splendor — Engine building
• Pandemic — Cooperative disease fighting
• Carcassonne — Tile-laying classic

Frequently Asked Questions

Is gaming cheaper than other hobbies?

Potentially, yes. £150/year for a small collection beats many hobbies. But uncontrolled collecting rivals any expensive hobby.

How do I convince others to try secondhand?

Frame as environmentally friendly. Show them the identical gameplay. Most objections are about status, not quality.

What about missing components in secondhand games?

Publishers often sell replacement parts. BGG files have printable replacements. Check completeness before finalising purchase.

Should I feel guilty buying secondhand instead of supporting publishers?

Secondhand markets extend game life and bring new players to the hobby—players who eventually buy new. Both markets coexist healthily.

How do I stop impulse buying?

Wishlists, waiting periods, and tracking cost-per-play of current collection. Seeing unplayed games as wasted money helps.

---

Final Thoughts

My 140-game collection taught me expensive lessons. Most of those games could have been borrowed, tested at cafés, or purchased secondhand after proven interest.

Budget gaming isn't about deprivation. It's about playing more and spending less. About valuing games by hours enjoyed, not money spent. About building collections that serve play, not performance.

The best game is always the one you're actually playing.

---

The Smoothie Wars Content Team creates educational gaming content. Their annual game budget is £150, their satisfaction is unlimited, and their shelf guilt is zero.